McMillan Law's office is in Tampa. I represent people in Jacksonville and everywhere else in Florida, and the free case review happens by phone or online, so you don't have to drive anywhere to get started.
Last reviewed October 10, 2026 by Jackson McMillan, Florida attorney
How a PCS move scrambles a Jacksonville credit report
Say your orders brought you to Naval Station Mayport or Naval Air Station Jacksonville after three addresses in four years. You find a house to rent in Duval County, or a dealer runs your credit for a second car, and the answer comes back no. When you pull the report, it shows things that don't belong to you:
- A credit card opened at an address in a state you've never lived in.
- A utility collection for the apartment you left two duty stations ago, run up by the tenant who moved in after you.
- Accounts that belong to a parent or sibling who shares your name.
- A balance from the landlord at your last base, even though you ended that lease the way your lease or the landlord's written agreement allowed when your orders came.
The first three are signs of what's called a mixed file. Bureaus sort incoming data by pieces of identity: name, address, birth date, part of a Social Security number. A family that moves every few years leaves a long trail of addresses, and every one of them is another place where a stranger's records can get attached to yours. My page on someone else's accounts on your credit report explains how that blending happens.
What Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion have to do
Congress passed the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) to set the rules for what a credit report may contain and how mistakes in it get corrected. Each bureau must use reasonable procedures aimed at the maximum possible accuracy of your file (15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b)). Letting another person's accounts into your file is the textbook example of a procedure falling short.
When you dispute, the bureau has 30 days to reinvestigate for free, or 45 days if you found the error on your free annual report. Within 5 business days of getting your dispute, it must pass your information to the company that reported the account. It has to weigh your proof itself, and it must remove or fix anything inaccurate, incomplete, or unverifiable.
That reporting company, which the law calls a furnisher, then owes its own investigation. Here is the catch for families on the move: the furnisher's duty that you can enforce in court is switched on only by a dispute that comes through a bureau. A letter or phone call to the old landlord or the card issuer, by itself, doesn't do it.
Upload the denial letter, your three reports, and any lease or move-out papers, and I'll tell you which entries to dispute and what the FCRA lets you do if the bureaus don't fix them.
A lease you closed out under orders, now reported as a debt
This one feels personal. You gave notice when the orders came, turned in the keys, and got the landlord's sign-off. Months later a collection agency is reporting a balance for rent on the months after you left.
If your paperwork shows the lease ended properly and nothing more was owed, that balance is an inaccuracy you can dispute. The documents carry the case. Under Eleventh Circuit precedent, which governs Florida, a furnisher is liable only for errors that are objectively and readily verifiable, so a dispute that turns on an open argument over what the lease meant is harder to win. A signed move-out agreement, your orders, and a final account statement showing zero due are what move a dispute from argument to fact.
Two cautions. Paying the collection won't erase it; the account usually just changes to "paid." And if the debt was sold to a new collector, that sale doesn't restart the seven-year reporting period. If a collector is reporting a debt you never owed at all, my guide to a collection that isn't yours goes step by step.
Military families and newcomers across Duval County and Northeast Florida
I represent people in Jacksonville, throughout Duval County, and across Northeast Florida, including families stationed at Naval Air Station Jacksonville and Naval Station Mayport. The same problems reach students and staff at the University of North Florida and Jacksonville University, who often show a string of short-term addresses on their reports too.
Moving often creates a practical problem on top of the legal one. Bureaus mail their results, or send them another way you authorize, after they finish, and any word that a removed account was restored also comes in writing. If that letter goes to your last duty station, you may never see it. Before you dispute, decide where you will actually be in six weeks and give every bureau that address.
The free case review happens online or by phone, so a coming deployment or the next set of orders doesn't have to stall it.
What a bureau or furnisher may owe your family
If a bureau or furnisher was careless, the FCRA lets you recover your actual damages. For a military family that can mean a rental you lost to another applicant, a higher rate on a car loan, application fees, hours on hold, and the stress of being treated like a bad credit risk just as you're settling into a new duty station.
If the violation was willful, which includes acting in reckless disregard of the law, you can seek either actual damages or statutory damages of $100 to $1,000, and a court may add punitive damages. You also need real harm. Florida state courts, including the Fourth Judicial Circuit courts that sit in Duval County, require it just as federal courts do, and the bad report reaching a landlord or lender is the most common example.
If you win, the FCRA shifts your reasonable attorney's fees and court costs onto the company that violated it. You don't pay me unless you win. I take these cases on contingency: no attorney's fees and no case costs owed to me unless you recover money. If a case is lost, a court can sometimes order the losing side to pay the other side's court costs, and some Florida laws, including the security deposit and deceptive practices statutes, also let the winner recover attorney's fees from the loser. I explain that risk before anything is filed, and every term is in a written agreement before you sign. My overview of credit report errors and FCRA claims covers how these cases are built.
Deadlines to track between moves
- 60 days after a denial to request the free report from the bureau the lender or landlord named.
- 30 days for the bureau's reinvestigation, stretched by up to 15 if you send new, relevant information during that time.
- 15 days for the bureau to describe how it checked your dispute, once you ask in writing.
- 2 years from discovering the violation to file suit, with an outer limit of 5 years from the violation. A dispute the bureau mishandled usually starts that clock, so keep every results letter with its envelope. If you are on active duty, federal law for servicemembers can pause these deadlines while you serve, so tell me your service dates rather than assuming the time has run.
Your Jacksonville checklist before the next set of orders
- Pull all three reports through AnnualCreditReport.com. Paid monitoring services can come with arbitration terms; the free official source can't make you accept any.
- Write out your address history since you joined, with dates, and circle every address on the report that isn't on your list.
- Gather the lease papers: your orders, the notice you gave, the landlord's move-out sign-off, and the final ledger or deposit accounting.
- Dispute by certified mail with each bureau that shows the error, and mail the creditor a copy. My guide to writing a credit dispute letter includes a sample.
- Hold off on paying a collector for a debt you don't believe you owe.
- Send it to me. Upload the reports, the denial letter, and your lease papers for a free case review, from Jacksonville or your next duty station.